A water filter pitcher improves the taste of water, but does it really remove contaminants? A study published in 2020 by Duke University and North Carolina State University shows that results vary widely from one filter to another, especially for PFAS, the “forever chemicals”.
New research suggests that water purifiers like Brita do not always work as well as expected. Results are completely inconsistent when it comes to filtering perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, the toxic chemicals known as PFAS.
These chemicals pose serious risks to human health, including kidney cancer and thyroid disease.
In this study, carbon filters, like those in pitchers, removed an average of 73% of PFAS, with wide variations: from almost all of them to almost none. Reverse osmosis systems and two-stage filters removed 94% or more.
Source: the study published on February 5, 2020 in the journal Environmental Science & Technology Letters.
PFAS in water
The researchers tested 76 point-of-use filters. In other words, these are the water purifiers you use every day at home, such as a Brita pitcher or a faucet attachment sold in home improvement stores. They also tested 13 point-of-entry, or whole-house, systems that filter the water as it enters the house, before it reaches the tap.
Water samples were taken from homes in one county and tested for PFAS and other chemicals. PFAS are a well-known and surprisingly widespread health risk. They have even shown up in takeout containers and grocery products. Because of their strong fluorine-carbon bonds, these “forever chemicals” take thousands of years to break down. When they are finally buried, the materials can leach out as plastic waste and end up in drinking water.
What a water filter pitcher does well, and what it does not
- It reduces the taste and odour of chlorine in municipal water.
- It does not reliably remove PFAS.
- It is not designed to treat water contaminated with bacteria: it is not a solution for unsafe well water.
- Its cartridge must be replaced often, or it loses its effectiveness.
PFAS in Canada
In 2024, Health Canada set an objective of 30 nanograms per litre for the sum of 25 PFAS in drinking water. It also recommends keeping their concentration as low as possible.
What to choose instead of a water filter pitcher?
For the water you drink, an under-sink reverse osmosis system (store page in French), with its own faucet, does much better than a filter pitcher. On a well, start with a water test: it tells us what to treat before choosing a system.
Want truly filtered water at home? Contact us or book an appointment: we will give you a quote and take care of the installation.
Phone: 1-888-840-0558 · Email: info@ecopureh2o.com · Contact us